SO, here's the material we finally decided on for the curtains. They will be straight valances and will most likely have a navy border around the bottom (and navy blackout curtains/shades over the windows). This means the room will be navy, lime green, brown, and aqua. Chad liked the sock monkeys and the red/aqua color scheme and I kept leaning toward aqua, lime green, and yellow themes, but we both loved this print. I'm so excited!
Photo from this etsy shop
Now to figure out the rest of the room! Thankfully I have talented friends that are going to help fill this room with homemade goodies. I can't wait!